Ethosome: A Promising Approach for Antifungal
Drug Delivery
Tejashree A. Ghadge*,
A.S. Kulkarni, S.H. Majumdar,
S.D. Chavare
Satara College of Pharmacy, Satara.
*Corresponding Author E-mail: tejashree.ghadge77@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Topical drug delivery system is most
preferred drug delivery system. Various skin infections are treated by transdermal drug delivery system. Fungal infection on skin
is most commonly found disease. To treat topical fungal infection many
semisolid dosage forms like ointment, cream and gels are used. These
formulations have limited therapeutic efficacy stability and safety profiles.
Stratum corneum layer of skin acts as major barrier
for topical formulation. Ethosomes are modified lipid
carrier that helps drug to reach deep into skin. Ethosomes
can be considered as one of the best replacement for carrying antifungal agent.
Ethosomes contain phospholipids and high concentration
of alcohol in vesicular formulation. An alcohol acts as permeation enhancer and
increase permeability of skin.
KEYWORDS: Antifungal,
Ethosome, Phospholipids, Lipid carrier, Vesicular
system.
INTRODUCTION:
Fungal infection of skin, hair and nail has
been increased in worldwide. The progression of fungal infection can berapid and serious. The fungal infection mainly cause by
various fungal species especially Candida
albicans which grow and spread on skin surface,
cause symptoms like itching, reddening, thickening of skin. Skin infections
including onchocytosis, vaginal infection are major
conditions which can be treated by Transdermal drug
delivery system. Topical semisolid dosage form mostly used to treat topical
fungal infection to avoid the systemic or other GIT irritations.
Topical treatment of fungal infections has
several superiorities including, targeting the site of infection reduction of
systemic side effects, high patient compliance. Different type of topical
antifungal compounds has been used in the treatment of various skin infections,
but they fail to penetrate deeply into stratum corneum
layer and they remain into the stratum corneum layer
which makes this system quite a failure skin acts as a major target but also
act as barrier for topical drug delivery. The main function of skin is to give
the protection from water loss. Physical protection is provided by outer most
layer of skin. The skin consists of mainly three layers subcutaneous tissue,
dermis, and epidermis. Stratum corneum is outermost
layer of epidermis. It consists of 10-25 layers of dead, elongated, fully
keratinized corneocytes, which embedded in matrix of
lipid bilayers. Stratum corneum
is main barrier to penetration through the skin. When topical formulation is
placed on skin active drug is required to penetrate through the stratum corneum into viable tissue. The limiting factor for these
processes is slow diffusion through the dead Horney layer of skin. To overcome
stratum corneum barrier, various mechanism have been
investigated, including use of chemical or physical enhancers. The examples of
these enhancers are iontophoresis, sonophoresis, liposomes, niosomes, transferosomes and ethosome. In novel drug delivery systems, noninvasive lipid
elastic vesicles are very useful in transdermal drug
delivery system to increase penetration. Drug encapsulated in lipid vesicles
prepared from phospholipids which transported into and across the skin. Lipid
vesicles may serve as nontoxic penetration enhancer for drugs. Many chemical
enhancers have been investigated e.g. liposome, niosome,
transferosomes and ethosome.
Liposome is unstable and poor skin permeation. Noisome also has poor
permeability. To overcome problem of permeability recently introduced new
vesicular carrier system i.e. ethosome
SKIN LAYER-
Fig. 1 Skin layer
ETHOSOME-
Ethosome are lipid elastic vesicles
which contain phospholipids and relatively high concentration of alcohol. Ethosomes are non-invasive delivery carries which penetrate
deep into skin layer. Ethosomes are soft, malleable
in nature. Ethosomes are mainly used for drugs which
are having low solubility and having high molecular weight. Ethosome
shows synergistic effect because of combination of phospholipids and high
concentration of ethanol in vesicular formulations they responsible for deeper
distribution and penetration in skin lipid bilayer
size of ethosome is vary from nanometers to microns.
Fig. 2 Ethosome vesicles
COMPOSITION OF
ETHOSOME
Table no-1 List of materials used in ethosome.
Material |
Examples |
Uses |
Phospholipid |
Soya phosphatidyl choline Egg phosphatidyl choline Dipalmitylphosphatidyl choline Distearylphosphatidyl choline |
Vesicles forming component |
Polyglycol |
Propylene glycol |
As a skin penetration enhancer |
Alcohol |
Isopropyl alcohol, Ethanol |
For providing the softness for vesicle membrane As a penetration enhancer |
Cholesterol |
Cholesterol |
For providing the stability to vesicle membrane. |
Vehicle |
Carbopol 934 |
As a gel former |
ADVANTAGES OF
ETHOSOME-
1. Ethosome is soft and malleable in
nature.
2. Ethosome contain
nontoxic raw material so ethosome formulation is safe
for use.
3. Ethosome has better stability and
solubility as compared to conventional vesicles.
4. Ethosome facilitates delivery of large
molecules as well as small molecules.
5. Ethosome is semisolid dosage form,
producing high patient compliance
6. This system is passive and
non-invasive in nature.
7. It enhances permeation of drug
molecules to and through the skin to the systemic circulation.
8. It avoids first pass metabolism
effects and their related side effects.
9. Ethosome drug delivery system can be
applied widely in Pharmaceutical, veterinary, cosmetic fields.
10. Method of preparation of ethosome is simple as compared to other transdermal
drug delivery system.
LIMITATIONS OF
ETHOSOMES-
1. Poor yield.
2. In case if shell locking is ineffective then
the ethosomes may coalescence and fall apart on transferinto water.
3. Loss of product during transfer from organic
to water media.
MECHANISM OF DRUG
PENETRATION [3] -
Generally, Ethosomes
are high fluidity of lipid layer low density layer; soft, malleable vesicles
penetrate from layer and in deep layer it release drug. Basically ethosome, mechanism of penetration occurs into mainly two
phases first is ethonolic effect and second is ethosome effect.
ETHANOLIC EFFECT-
In this phase, ethosome
vesicles contain ethanol in relatively high concentration. Ethanol acts as
permeation enhancer and it fluidizes the lipid bilayer.
Also it decreases density of lipid multilayer.
ETHOSOME EFFECT-
Ethosome is soft and malleable
vesicles. Vesicles easily penetrate from lipid layer because of its decreasing
density and increase fluidity. Ethosome vesicles are
penetrate deep into skin layer it fuse with lipid layer
Fig. 3 Mechanism
of drug penetration
METHOD OF
PREPARATION OF ETHOSOME-:
Ethosomes can be prepared by two
methods, one is hot method and other method is cold method.
Cold method:
This is the most common method for the
preparation of ethosome formulation. In covered
vessels phospholipids, drug and lipid materials are dissolved in ethanol with
vigorous stirring. In this mixture propylene glycol or other polyol is added during stirring. This mixture is heated to
300C in water bath. At same time water is heated in separate vessels
at 300c. Then water is added in previous mixture, which is then stirred
for 5min. incovered vessel. Vesicles size of
formulation is decreased by using sonication or extrusion method.
Mixture is dissolved in ethanol in covered vessel.
Propylene glycol or other polyol
is added
Water is added at same temperature (300c)
Stir for 5 min. in vessels ad size reduction achieve by
using sonication or extrusion
Fig-4 Flow chart
for procedure of cold method.
Hot method:
In this method disperse phospholipids
dissolved in water by heating in a water bath at 40 ⁰C until a colloidal solution is obtained. In a separate
vessel ethanol and propylene glycol are mixed properly and this mixture is heated
up to 400 C. At equal temperature, add the organic phase into the
aqueous phase. Drug is dissolved in
water or ethanol depending on its solubility. The vesicle size of ethosomal formulation can be decreased to the desire extent
using probe sonication or extrusion method.
Fig: 5 Flow chart
for procedure of hot method.
CHARACTERIZATIONS
OF ETHOSOMES [9]:
1.
VESICLE SHAPE-
Ethosomes can be easily visualized by
using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and by scanning electron
microscopy (SEM).
2.
VESICLE SIZE AND ZETA
POTENTIAL-
Particle size of the ethosomes
can be determined by dynamic light scattering (DLS) and photon correlation
spectroscopy (PCS). Zeta potential of the formulation can be measured by Zeta
meter.
3.
TRANSITION TEMPERATURE-
The transition temperature of the
vesicular lipid systems can be determined by using differential scanning
calorimeter (DSC).
4.
DRUG ENTRAPMENT-
The entrapment efficiency of ethosomescan be measured by the ultracentrifugation
technique.
5.
SURFACE TENSION MEASUREMENT-
The surface tension activity of drug in
aqueous solution can be measured by the ring method in a Du Nouy
ring tensiometer.
6.
DRUG CONTENT-
Drug content of the ethosomes
can be determined using UV spectrophotometer. This can also be quantified by a
modified high performance liquid chromatographic method.
7.
STABILITY STUDIES-
The stability of vesicles can be
determined by assessing the size and structure of the vesicles over time. Mean
size is measured by DLS and structure changes are observed by TEM.
8.
SKIN PERMEATION STUDIES-
The ability of the ethosomal
preparation to penetrate into the skin layers can be determined by using confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM).
APPLICATION OF
ETHOSOME-
1.
Delivery of anti-viral drugs-
Oral administration of
antiviral drug is associated with strong side effects. To overcome this side
effects and also to increase permeation of drugs through skin ethosome drug delivery system are used. Zidovudin
and Acyclovir have oral side effects and also poor skin penetration. This
problem is avoided by using ethosome drug delivery
system.
2.
Topical delivery of DNA-
Skin acts as excellent
protective barrier and also immunologically active and able to express genes. Ethosome is used for topical delivery of DNA molecules to
express genes in skin cells. Touitou et.al. [19]In
their study encapsulated the GFP-CMV- driven transfecting
construct into ethosome formulation. Topically
applied ethosomes GFP-CMV- driven transfecting
construct enabled efficient delivery and expression of genes in skin cells. Ethosome could be used as carriers for gene therapy
applications.
3.
Transdermal delivery of hormones-
Oral administration of hormones
is associated with GIT problem also it has low oral bioavailability. Skin
permeation of testosterone ethosome has better
permeation than marketed patch of testosterone.
4.
Delivery of antibiotics-
Oral or conventional oral
therapy of antibiotics has several side effects. To avoid this oral side
effects topical drug delivery system is better choice but it possess low
permeability to deep skin layers. Ethosome contain
antibiotics can be used to overcome side effects and also it increases
permeability through skin.
5.
Delivery of Problematic Drug molecules-
A large biogenic molecule such
as peptides or protein is difficult for oral delivery. Non-invasive delivery of
proteins is a better option for overcoming the problems associated with oral
delivery. Touitou investigated the effect of ethosome insulin delivery in lowering blood glucose levels
(BGL) in vivo in normal and diabetic
SDI rats.
6.
Delivery of anti-Parkinsonism
agent-
Dayan and Touitou
[19] prepared ethosome formulation of psycholractive drug trihexyphenidyl
HCl. Ethosome-THP
formulation indicated better skin permeation. Its use for better management of
Parkinson disease.
Table no.-2 Example of drug molecules used in ethosome
drug delivery.
Sr.no. |
Drug |
Category |
Application(s) |
1 |
Ciclopiroxolamine |
Antifungal drug |
For treatment of cutaneous candidiasis infection |
2 |
Amphotericin-B |
Antifungal drug |
Treatment of topical fungal
infection.( Leishmaniasis) |
3 |
Miconazole |
Imidazole antifungal drug |
For treatment of fungal infection. |
4 |
Ketoconazole |
Antifungal drug |
Treatment of topical fungal
infection. |
5 |
Clotrimazole |
Antifungal drug |
For treatment of fungal
infection of candida species. |
6 |
Azidothymidine |
Antiviral agent |
For treatment acquired immune
deficiency syndrome |
7 |
Tizanidine HCl |
Muscle relaxant drug |
Used to treatmuscle spasms |
8 |
Finasteride |
Anti-androgens |
For treatment of benign
prostatic hyperplasia and androgenetic alopecia. |
9 |
Indinavir sulfate |
Antiviral drug |
For treatment of HIV-1
infection. |
10 |
Ketoprofen |
Non-steroidal
anti-inflammatory drug |
For treatment of
musculoskeletal pain |
11 |
Tetrandrine |
Antiathritis |
For treatment of arthritis. |
12 |
Acyclovir |
Antiviral drug |
For treatment of Herpes labialis. |
13 |
Insulin |
Anti-diabetics |
For treatment of Diabetes. |
14 |
Repaglinide |
Anti-Diabetic drug |
For treatment of Diabetes. |
15 |
Testosterone |
Hormones |
For treatment of male hypogonodism. |
16 |
Erythromycin |
Antimicrobial |
Efficient healing of S.aureus. |
17 |
Diclofenac |
NSAID |
Used inboth acute and chronic inflammation |
18 |
Cavamax W7 |
Anti-psoriatic drug and anti vitiligo |
For treatment of chronic
immunological disorders. |
19 |
Cromolyn Sodium |
Ant allergic drug |
For treatment of allergic
exercise induced asthma and food allergy. |
20 |
Piroxicam |
NSAID |
For treatment of pain and
inflammatory disorders. |
21 |
Ligustrazine |
Antioxidant |
For treatment of angina
pectoris |
22 |
Tacrolimus |
Immunosupressor. |
For treatment of atopic dermatitis. |
CONCLUSION:
Conventional
Formulations are used across the world for treating fungal infections, these
formulation have limitations in term of therapeutic efficacy stability and
safety profiles. Topical antifungal drug were unstable to penetrate deeply
across the stratum corneum and make these system
quite a failure in case of topical as transdermal
care of fungal infection. These drawbacks can be overcome by ethosome drug delivery system. Liposome, transferosomes cannot pass through stratum corneum. Ethosome is novel
vesicular systems which are best alternatives to liposome as it is having high
penetration rate through stratum corneum barrier. Ethosome initiated a new area in vesicular research for Transdermal drug delivery for provide better permeation.
REFERENCES:
1) Abhishek Chandel, Vishal Patil, Rohit
Goyal, Hitesh Dhamija and
Bharat Parashar-(2012), Ethosome:
A novel approach towards transdermal drug delivery,
International Journal of Pharmaceutical and Chemical Science. Vol-1(2) 563-569.
2) A Satish Chandra, Vedha Hari, Annapurna Anusha, “Ethosomes: A Noval Vasicular Carrier for Enhanced Dermal Delivery of Azidothymidine”, International Journal of Advances in
Pharmaceutical Research, ISSN: 2230 – 7583 Feb. 2012/ Vol. 3 / Issue. 2
/pg.no.746 – 752.
3) Angadi Jyothi, K. Sai Sowjanya, Sreekanth
Nama, B. Karuna, Chandu Babu Rao,
(2013), “Ethosomes: A Novel Drug Carrier for Transdermal Drug Delivery”, International Journal of
Innovative Drug Discovery, Vol3, Issue 1, pg.no.39-44.
4) Ananda Kumar.Ch, Dr.Rajeswar
Dutt. “Ethosomes: A Novel Transdermal Drug DeliverySystem”,
WorldJournal of Pharmaceutical Research Volume 3,
Issue 3, ISSN 2277 – 7105, pg.no. 3740-3750
5) Chao
Fan, Xinru Li, Yanxia Zhou,
Yong Zhao, Shujin Ma, Wenjing
Li, Yan Liu, and Guiling Li (2013), “Enhanced Topical
Delivery of Tetrandrine by Ethosomes
for Treatment of Arthritis”,Hindawi Publishing
Corporation Biomed Research International Volume 2013, Article ID 161943, 13
pages.
6) Manish
K. Chourasia, Lifeng Kang,
Sui Yung Chan(2011), “Nanosized ethosomes
bearing ketoprofen for improved transdermal
delivery”, Results in Pharma Sciences1 pg.no. 60–67.
7) R. Rathodre, H. Khambele, S. Jain
(2013), “Preparation and characterization of Repaglinide
Loaded Ethosome gel for treatment of NIDDM”.
International Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biological Archives-2013 4(2)
385-390
8) Pooja Sharma, Anuj Chawla, Sandeep Arora, Pravin Pawar
(2012), “Novel drug delivery approaches on antiviral and antiretroviral
agents”, Journal of Advanced Pharmaceutical Technology & Research Jul-Sep
2012 Vol. 3,147-159.
9) Parth K Shah, S H Majumdar
(2014), “Patent Review on Ethosomes: Novel Vesicular
Carrier for Enhanced Transdermal Drug Delivery
System”, Inventi Rapid: NDDS Vol. 2014, Issue 2.
10) Patel Bhoomi J and Patel Jitendra L,
“Design and Development of Transferosomes of Fluconazole for Topical Drug Delivery System.” An
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Pharma
Science Monitor 5(2), Sup-1, Apr-Jun 2014. Pg. no.298-312.
11) Poonam Verma, K. Pathak (2010), “Therapeutic and cosmeceutical
potential of ethosomes: An overview”, Journal of
Advanced Pharmaceutical Technology & Research, Jul-Sep 2010 , Vol
1 ,Issue 3 pg.no.274-282.
12) Sarat Chandran, Dr.
Arun Shirwaikar, Dr. A. Sarala Devi & Anjali Dominic
(2011), “Development and evaluations of ethosomal
formulation containing Ketoconazole”, Asian Journal
of Biochemical and Pharmaceutical Research, Vol-1,303-309.
13) Sadhna Khatry,
“Novel drug delivery system for antifungal therapy”, International Journal of
Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Science, vol-2, 2010, 6-9.
14) Saeed Ghanbarzadeh
and Sanam Arami, “Enhanced Transdermal Delivery of Diclofenac Sodium via Conventional Liposomes, Ethosomes and Transferosomes”, Hindawi
Publishing Corporation Biomed Research International Volume 2013, Article ID
616810, 7 pages.
15) Vivek Dave, Dhirendra
Kumar, Shaila Lewis, Sarvesh
Paliwal, “Ethosome for
Enhanced Transdermal Drug Delivery of Aceclofenac”,
International Journal of Drug Delivery, (2010) 81-92
16) Rahul G.S Maheshwari,
Rakesh K. Tekade, Piyoosh A. Sharma, Gajanan Darwhekar, Abhishek Tyagi, Rakesh P. Patel , Dinesh K. Jain,
“Ethosomes and ultra-deformable liposomes
for transdermal delivery of Clotrimazole:
A comparative assessment”, Saudi Pharmaceutical Journal, (2012) 20, 161–170
17) Rita Cortesi, Laura Ravani, Enea Menegatti, M. Drechsler, Elisabetta Esposito,
“Colloidal Dispersions for the Delivery of Acyclovir: A Comparative Study”,
Indian Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences,November -
December 2011, pg.no. 687-693.
18) Sevgi Güngör, M. Sedef Erdal, Buket
Aksu, “New Formulation Strategies in Topical
Antifungal Therapy”, Journal of Cosmetics, Dermatological Sciences and
Applications, (2013) 3, pg.no. 56-65.
19) Touitou E, Dayan N, Bergelson
L, Godin B, Eliaz M, “Ethosomes - novel vesicular carriers for enhanced delivery:
characterization and skin penetration properties.”J Control Release. 2000 Apr
3; 65(3):403-18.
20) Touitou E, Alkabes M,
Dayan N.,“Ethosomes: Novel lipid vesicular system for
enhanced delivery”. Pharm. Res. 1997; 14: 305-306.
Received
on 22.02.2015 Accepted on 05.03.2015
©A&V
Publications all
right reserved
Research J.
Topical and Cosmetic Sci. 6(1):Jan.–June 2015 page 32-37
DOI: 10.5958/2321-5844.2015.00005.9